PDA

View Full Version : Who was the star of the Monte ?



pino
28th January 2008, 10:48
I know Loeb deserve it, but I gave my vote to Chris Atkinson, wasn't easy to keep tarmac specialist Duval behind him...Let me also mention Broccoli's amazing result/performance on Clio :up:

Josti
28th January 2008, 10:59
The obvious pick would be Atkinson, but apart from the final result, Duval did equaly good. New team, new car, new codriver. For that, I'd pick Francois.

Donney
28th January 2008, 11:04
I chose Andersson, new to 4wd, new car and lots of problems throughout the rally. I'm impressed by his results.

Viktory
28th January 2008, 11:14
Yeah, I also picked PG.

Tomi
28th January 2008, 11:16
i choose Loeb, he did not give much chanses to the others, a win by minutes even cruising the half of the event makes it difficult to call anyone else a star.

miksu
28th January 2008, 11:19
PG for me, mostly because pace of the suzuki was more or less surprise for me and pace of PG was the real surprise! Maybe tarmac is easier for a newcomer than gravel, but still it was a great performance imho!

Mirek
28th January 2008, 11:22
I doubt if to vote Atkinson or P-G. But anyway Loeb has bad luck that he's permanent star so that noone will vote him :D

Magnus
28th January 2008, 11:28
Loeb is always the star, so it´s no point in giving it to him. I voted PG, but bpth Atko and Duval did very good jobs!

jonas_mcrae
28th January 2008, 11:30
PG for sure, for a car with all those problems on day one and first time in wrc, its a great surprise, of course he benefited from the retirements, but he posted some really good times.

I am evil Homer
28th January 2008, 11:36
Brocolli - the speed and control in the Clio compared to the N4 guys was superb, made them look very ordinary.

Of the WRC guys...Loeb was in cruise control god knows how far ahead he could have been so it has to be PG for bringing the Suzuki home and doing well on the debut. Atko was also very good.

Mirek
28th January 2008, 11:39
Broccoli was also good but in case of almost no competition in classes below WRC his perofmance is hard to judge.

N.O.T
28th January 2008, 11:42
Hmmm...Brocolli and Mercier for me....but i voted for Atkinson given his car and the guy he beat.

Loeb did nothing more than his usual massarce of the opposition.....

N
28th January 2008, 12:00
Loeb, you can clearly see the difference in speed when he passes you on a stage compared to other drivers, he is just faster. The rally was very tricky and he managed to win it in such a style.

Tomski
28th January 2008, 12:20
My heart said anyone but Loeb, but my head said he's the only choice. No one else was near him.

Come on guys don't let him make it 5 championships in a row!

Daniel
28th January 2008, 12:20
Conrad. He got further through a WRC event in a WRCAR than he has before. Well done Conrad. Most improved award goes to you.

leno
28th January 2008, 12:24
:champion: atko king of monte

J4MIE
28th January 2008, 12:52
Just because Seb usually gets it, doesn't make him any less worthy of winning it once more.

Nobody else can come close to him :)

jure dvorsek
28th January 2008, 13:08
Loeb-no doubt !! Second after him Alex Broccoli.

N.O.T
28th January 2008, 13:16
I enjoyed the fact that this time Loeb cleared the competiton in 2 stages....usually he needed 2 days...but still i think Brocolli and Mercier did a fantastic job.

A.F.F.
28th January 2008, 13:38
Subaru.

The car was clearly faster and more important, reliable than in years. And they got both cars to finish line scoring decent manu points.

DonJippo
28th January 2008, 13:42
Natural choice would be Loeb but Atko did a great job keeping Duval behind so my vote goes to him.

[Madeira-Rally]
28th January 2008, 13:57
I voted in PG Andersson..

He did an excellent job in his debut with a WRC!

Shrike
28th January 2008, 13:59
This was tough. For me it was a toss up between Atko and PG.

Fischer
28th January 2008, 14:56
I would say Duval, because he drove like a maniac and because he would have been 3rd if he hadn't stalled at the start of the stage.

Tom206wrc
28th January 2008, 15:25
To me, Atkinson was the star thanks to his resistance against Dudu for final podium place ;)

Abarth
28th January 2008, 15:28
From the choices I voted PG, but I am equally impressed by Brocolli for his superb result.

I am impressed by the R3 cars, promise a lot for the future if the price is kept down !

Mv Toy
28th January 2008, 17:52
Very tough!
Loeb,Atkinson and PG all of them deserves it!

Woodeye
28th January 2008, 19:19
Seb. Nobody else didn't have a chance to win Monte.

MJW
28th January 2008, 22:19
My vote would go to Pirelli - OK JML had punctures, but they were self inflicted. Overall I think they contributed positively to a world championship round. I know it was playing to teh spectators with such a massive lead but Loeb was quite sliding on the Monye superspecial. Of the available choices on the poll I go with Atko.

GigiGalliNo1
29th January 2008, 04:03
pft atko...

grugsticles
29th January 2008, 06:07
Although I think Chris did a dammed good job at getting a podium with the struggling Subaru, I think PG deserves it.
Hes jumped in a new car which is no where near up to its potential speed, had little Monte experience and beaten his far more experienced team mate (Toni) on possibly the most difficuilt surface of the WRC calendar.

Top notch!

koko0703
29th January 2008, 06:26
I voted for Atkinson on his 2nd career podium finish but Duval equally deserves the credit for making the battle for podium very interesting and nail biting. Both Chris and Duval did fatastic job, especially they didn't go off the road when pusing hard :D

CABAIO E'LONA
29th January 2008, 09:57
I chose.... Per Gunnar Andersson...

V.Gatev
29th January 2008, 10:35
Alex Broccoli - he make history with this Clio R3. After him - P.G. Andersson.

Brother John
29th January 2008, 11:39
"Does not itch me at all" for the fifth time could Sebastien Loeb win the Rally Monte Carlo and over takes thereby Rallylegends such as Sandro Munari, Tommi Maekinen, or Walter Röhrl.
NO COMPARISON: Walter Röhrl does not see Monte today as at his times, it´s completely different.
Loeb had yesterday won the Rally Monte Carlo for the fifth time and had set up thus a new record. "that today is however completely different world and completely different Rally as in order to my times with the special stages, he would have to win this Rally already ten times " alludes Röhrl to the clearly shorter distance and the absence of the famous "night of the Turinni". "at that time there were still 15 people, which could win.
Today it is unfortunately only one driver. It is unfortunate that Sebastien Loeb is perfectly competitionless. I would also gladly in former times to have had that same shance.
" Respect for the today's world champion " say Walter.

Zes
29th January 2008, 13:07
"Does not itch me at all" for the fifth time could Sebastien Loeb win the Rally Monte Carlo and over takes thereby Rallylegends such as Sandro Munari, Tommi Maekinen, or Walter Röhrl.
NO COMPARISON: Walter Röhrl does not see Monte today as at his times, it´s completely different.
Loeb had yesterday won the Rally Monte Carlo for the fifth time and had set up thus a new record. "that today is however completely different world and completely different Rally as in order to my times with the special stages, he would have to win this Rally already ten times " alludes Röhrl to the clearly shorter distance and the absence of the famous "night of the Turinni". "at that time there were still 15 people, which could win.
Today it is unfortunately only one driver. It is unfortunate that Sebastien Loeb is perfectly competitionless. I would also gladly in former times to have had that same shance.
" Respect for the today's world champion " say Walter.

Couldn't agree more :up:

MikeD
29th January 2008, 14:07
Great job by PG and Atkinson, but give them a C4 and they would still be lightyears behind Loeb on these roads. Not doubt Loeb gets my vote!

urabus-denoS2000
29th January 2008, 18:13
PG.First rally with a WRC with a new car,strong performance

Xsara Fan
29th January 2008, 18:18
Citroen Sport. New engine, new tyres, new boss but the same GREAT result!

jens
29th January 2008, 19:13
Sure Loeb was unbeatable, but among the others the most outstanding performance came from Chris. ;) He seems to have very good nerves as it seems to become like a tradition that he manages to win close battles in the end (also against Hirvonen and Latvala last year in MC and NZ respectively).

Kamikaze
29th January 2008, 20:07
Citroen Sport. New engine, new tyres, new boss but the same GREAT result!

You should tell Sordo this :D

TKM
30th January 2008, 00:36
Atko's result wasn't at all surprising, in fact I had him at third in the pickups.

He finished 4th last year and Gronholm has since retired, so it was obvious that Chris was capable of a podium this year.

That being said, I doubt the POS Subaru will back it up on snow or gravel. It will no doubt break something on the rougher surface (although I hope I'm proved wrong).

Catiocha7
30th January 2008, 10:03
Atkinson :)

Anti-Lag-Rocks
30th January 2008, 11:40
Got to be Atkinson.

Have watched the guy start his career in the forests of Queensland as a young lad, and now he is fighting for a Podium on the Monte (which I was also spectating at this year). What a great journey for him.

He has had a rough ride so far, but I am hoping he will have a good season this year.

I had the spilts SMS'ed to me and I really doubted he would be able to hold off flying Frankie... but he did. Woo!

Xsara Fan
30th January 2008, 18:22
You should tell Sordo this :D
:)

Micke_VOC
30th January 2008, 21:46
I voted PG, strong drive by him...

Atkin was really good too

jso1985
31st January 2008, 23:34
"Does not itch me at all" for the fifth time could Sebastien Loeb win the Rally Monte Carlo and over takes thereby Rallylegends such as Sandro Munari, Tommi Maekinen, or Walter Röhrl.
NO COMPARISON: Walter Röhrl does not see Monte today as at his times, it´s completely different.
Loeb had yesterday won the Rally Monte Carlo for the fifth time and had set up thus a new record. "that today is however completely different world and completely different Rally as in order to my times with the special stages, he would have to win this Rally already ten times " alludes Röhrl to the clearly shorter distance and the absence of the famous "night of the Turinni". "at that time there were still 15 people, which could win.
Today it is unfortunately only one driver. It is unfortunate that Sebastien Loeb is perfectly competitionless. I would also gladly in former times to have had that same shance.
" Respect for the today's world champion " say Walter.

Funny thing is that with longer rallyes like they were until the 90's, Loeb would still win even more rallyes I think, he makes much less mistakes comparing to the other current drivers.

Helstar
1st February 2008, 03:49
Too easy to name Loeb, would be a surprise when he WON'T be the star of a rally this year ^^

So I choose Atkinson. Beating again his team-mate Solberg + close battle in the whole rally (last year against Mikko), finally got a deserved 3rd position, not bad at all ...

Second place, Broccoli. Just amazing. He was just another level compared to all the others Gr.N drivers. This guy earned another 3 fans (my brother, his friend and me) who were impressed by his driving skills.

Last but not least, special congratulation to ROMEYER because he is a showman and made the spectators happy with all his sideways action in the 'old' 206 :)
He also had a close call which I have in video, will share soon...

millencolin
1st February 2008, 11:57
Atko no doubt... cause im too patriotic to see otherwise

mdesign
1st February 2008, 12:15
I personally think that sordo also did a good monte carlo (not result wise). Although I would not vote for him, I guess he was the only guy that shown some pace near to Loeb's pace.

Langdale Forest
1st February 2008, 19:19
Atkinson for getting 3rd in the old Subaru.

Helstar
3rd February 2008, 04:55
Last but not least, special congratulation to ROMEYER because he is a showman and made the spectators happy with all his sideways action in the 'old' 206 :)
He also had a close call which I have in video, will share soon...
Here's a little video of Romeyer with also the 'close call' ... sorry I don't know why Virtualdub excluded the sound :s
I have to fix this for the 'whole' video remix (it's about 1 hour !). Take this one as a preview xD

http://www.mediafire.com/?euwxjx1brpy