PDA

View Full Version : Who did the commentary for the BBC on Thurs?



grantb4
23rd May 2009, 04:45
And in particular who is the bloke writing the Williams book?

inimitablestoo
23rd May 2009, 18:03
That would be Maurice Hamilton, ably assisted by Ian Phillips of Force India, at least in session 2. I haven't been following session 1 all year, but I believe it's usually David Croft and Anthony Davidson in that one (as in Saturday's session).

christophulus
23rd May 2009, 19:04
Yep, it's always been Croft and Davidson in P1 when I've watched it.

acescribe
23rd May 2009, 19:37
No, on BBC Sports Xtra, online and the 'red button' Maurice Hamilton and Ian Phillips do the Friday P1 and P2 sessions (albeit Thursday this week obviously) Then David Croft and Anthony Davidson take over for P3, qualifying and the race.

Oli_M
23rd May 2009, 19:39
Certainly was Croft and Davidson for P1 on Thursday and then Hamilton and Phillips for P2, and pretty sure it has been this way for all other Friday's I have watched (via Red Button).

UltimateDanGTR
23rd May 2009, 21:13
Davidson is such a good asset to the Beebs commentary team-even if it is only in practice sessions. He's got that array of knowledge etc and he's just enjoyable and interesting to listen to-as well as being imformative. so maybe Davidson not having a seat isnt so bad-he can give us great insight and analysis!

BDunnell
23rd May 2009, 21:24
Davidson is such a good asset to the Beebs commentary team-even if it is only in practice sessions. He's got that array of knowledge etc and he's just enjoyable and interesting to listen to-as well as being imformative. so maybe Davidson not having a seat isnt so bad-he can give us great insight and analysis!

I agree. He is an outstanding broadcaster — one of the best expert analysts to be heard on any sports coverage.

wedge
24th May 2009, 15:25
He would've been outstanding if he didn't interrupt his flow all the time with "errr, errrr ...err,err ....err errr".


And he's no rookie either, he's been commentating a good few years

woody2goody
24th May 2009, 23:41
They should use Ant for the TV red button after the race.